Sunday, January 6, 2008

Emapthetic Roman Key Card?

A new idea popped into my head this weekend that has me thinking of a better approach. I had a discussion concerning answering RKCB with a "useful void" in an auction where my shortness was known. It seems a waste of space to use most approaches. Consider 4NT-P-? If you "skip up" and answer 5NT, 6♣, 6D, or 6♥ with a void, you lose a lot of space for queen-asks and side asks and the like, to show something that might be irrelevant (partner might have the Ace, after all). It seemed easier to just answer and then have partner bid, say, 6♣ to ask if you club shortness was a void or not.

But, then I thought through another idea I had earlier, and a "better way" became obvious. The idea is to use an ask-or-answer approach.

Consider a simple auction. 2♣(strong, artificial)-P-2♠(spade positive)-P-4♥(spade fit, shortness in hearts). Now what?

Using the "ask or answer" approach, Responder could bid 4NT as RKCB with the heart Ace, making the void showing irrelevant, or less relevant. Without the heart Ace, Responder "answers" and bids 5♣...5♠ as his hypo key card answer to a hypo 4NT from Opener, but without the heart Ace.

How about another situation. Hearts are agreed. One person has shown shortness somewhere. 4♠ by his partner denies the missing Ace and is an ask-or-answer relay. His partner can then bid 4NT as Exclusion (void or stiff Ace) or answer (singleton). 4NT instead of 4♠ is RKCB but promises the Ace in the short suit.

This allows the RKCB responses to stay at the normal level but resolves the "stiff or void" question "before" the answers. This approach suffers from the loss of other meanings for the five-level calls and, accordingly, should probably only be used in pre-discussed auctions or types of auctions.

An example from real life.

Opener: ♠AKJxxxx ♥Kxx [D]AQx ♣void

Responder: ♠Q10xx ♥AQx [D]Kxx ♣xxx

2[D]: 22+ or 9+ tricks, 4+ spades, unbalanced

3♥: Power spade raise, Qxxx+ or xxxxx+ support, very good hand

3NT: 6+ spades

4♣: Shortness ask

4♠: club shortness (minimal LTC)

5♣: one(1430), no club Ace

5♥: King of hearts?

5NT: yes, but no diamond King

6D: diamond Queen?

6NT: yes, but no heart Queen


Compare that with the auction up to the 4♠ call and 4NT as just RKCB. Opener has a 5D response (0/3). He jumps instead to 6♣ to show the void and 0/3. Responder can ask for the heart King (6♥) but not the diamond Queen.

1 comment:

Hotel Key Card said...

I find the valuable information is provided by you about to the Emapthetic Roman Key Card. Roman Keycard is an improvement on standard Blackwood, based on the idea that the king of trump can be as important as any ace.